Overturning DOMA will increase LGBT rights in the workplace

The impact of the Supreme Court decision overturning the Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA) will be felt in the workplace.

First of all overturning DOMA will expand anti-discrimination protections and partner benefits to gay, lesbian and transgendered employees who are employed by the federal government.

Overturning DOMA will also probably benefit LGBT employees not working for the federal government. One argument is that that banning LGBT discrimination in federal employment will ease acceptance of extending anti-discrimination protections to gays and lesbians in the workforce as a whole. Legislation has been introduced that would explicitly extend protections offederal and state fair employment statutes to gays and lesbians.

From a political point of view, explicitly extending fair employment statutes to cover gays and lesbians probably won’t be feasible until at least 2015 depending on the outcome of the 2014 elections. Politicians in red states in both parties may be wary of conservative backlash if they support extending fair employment practices to gays and lesbians. That same reticence will probably be displayed by Senate Majority Leader Harry Reed who needs to Democrats to win in several conservative states in order to hold on to the majority.

But today’s decision overturning DOMA may further open the door to judicially expanding employment statutes to gays and lesbians. Justice Kennedy and the liberal bloc struck down DOMA on 5th/14th amendment equal protection grounds. If state’s can’t discriminate against gays in marriage on equal protection grounds it doesn’t make logical sense that the 5/14th amendment allows employment discrimination against gays.

It is arguable that gays, lesbian and transgendered people already have the protections of our fair employment laws under the theory of sex-plus discrimination which prohibits discrimination based on sexual stereotypes . In Smith v. City of Salem, Ohio the 6th Circuit Court of Appeals extended protections under the sex-plus theory to a male firefighter who started identifying as a woman.  In Lewis v. Heartland Inns of America, the conservative 8th Circuit Court of Appeals upheld a finding of possible finding of sex discrimination for a woman who was described by her boss as having  “an Ellen DeGeneres kind of look.” Though the 8th Circuit didn’t make any reference to sexual orientation in the decision, it is obvious that “Ellen DeGeneres” is a code word for “lesbian”. It makes sense to me that opposite sex attraction is a stereotype for each gender and that discrimination against gays, lesbians and transgendered people should be covered under the theory of sex-plus discrimination. I think courts will be increasingly be forced to rule that way in the wake of today’s decision on DOMA stating that discrimination against gays and lesbians runs afoul of the 5th/14th amendments. Another possible factor working in favor expanding fair employment protections to gays and lesbians are recent Supreme Court decisions interpreting federal fair employment law favorably for employers.  It’s easy to conceive of moderately conservative judge in the mode of Supreme Court Justice Anthony Kennedy judicially extending fair employment law to gays and lesbians with the understanding that it will likely be more difficult employees to win fair employment suits.

Until Congress and/or our state legislatures act, gays and lesbians are not guaranteed equal rights at work. But thanks to today’s decision overturning DOMA, I think courts will be more open to extending workplace rights to the LGBT community regardless of what is done in the legislative branch.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: